PHOTOSENSITIZERS in MEDICINE
Department of Radiation Biology
The Norwegian Radium Hospital
Montebello, N-0310 Norway
The picture below (left) shows a basal cell carcinoma. A physician wants to treat this skin cancer, but is unsure about the extent of the malignant tissue. What part of the lesion is cancerous? Where are the borders? Physicians can use photosensitizers to answer these questions. They can treat the area with a photosensitizer, such as 5-aminolevulinic acid, and then look at it using a blue light, which causes the photosensitizer to fluoresce (right). The pink/red fluorescent areas define the extent of the malignant lesion. In this module you will learn more about photosensitizers and the properties that make them useful for applications like this.
Photosensitizers have evolved over millions of years, mainly for defence against microbial
and herbivorous attack. Some of these compounds have been found to
have therapeutic properties, and these and derivatives of these compounds
as well as new chemical entities, have been developed for therapeutic
and diagnostic purposes. Other biomolecules have the potential to
become photosensitizers upon minor modifications, and some man-made
compounds have photosensitizer properties that are mostly unwanted.
Here, some basic properties of photosentizers
will be described,
followed by an overview of the most important groups of known photosensitizers.
Review of Basic Properties of Photosentizers
The first law of photochemistry states that "only light absorbed by a
molecule can produce photochemical change in that molecule". When light
encounters a molecule, it can either be scattered or absorbed. A
molecule that has absorbed a quantum of light is said to be excited
, and molecules that can be excited by the absorption of visible light are named chromophores
The absorption spectrum of a molecule reflects its probability of
transition between the ground state and any of the vibrational and
rotational levels of its first and higher excited states. The
absorption spectrum, characterized by the molar absorption coefficient
(previously known as the extinction coefficient) at a particular
wavelength, is described by Beer-Lambert's law:
is the molar absorption coefficient, I0
is the fluence rate of the incoming light, I
is the fluence rate of the transmitted light, d
is the thickness of the sample, c
is the molar concentration, and OD is the optical density. Absorption can be reported either as % transmittance
(100 x I/I0
) or as absorbance
). The wavelength of the peak of absorbance (Imax
the spectral shape are dependent on the local concentration of
absorbing molecules, pH, polarity of the solvent, binding to other
molecules, aggregation and temperature.
A molecule that has absorbed a light quantum is excited to the first or
higher excited states (see the modules on Basic Photophysics and Photochemistry). The higher excited states are dissipated very
fast (ps) down to the first excited singlet state with a lifetime of
the order of ns. This excited state can be deactivated by the release of
heat (nonradiative decay), emitted as fluorescence of a wavelength
equal to or longer than that of the excitation light, or by undergoing
intersystem crossing (ISC). Photochemistry may also occur, but usually
with a low probability, due to the short lifetime of this state.
Exceptions are intramolecular modifications, e.g., those that cause photoisomerization, as in bilirubin, upon the light treatment of hyperbilirubinemia (jaundice) in newborns. ISC is usually forbidden (selection rules), but macrocyclic molecules with
conjugated double bond systems (
-electron system) are exceptions and allow for long-lived (µs-ms)
triplet states. The triplet state may react in two ways, either a Type I mechanisms
involving electron or hydrogen atom transfer from one molecule to the
other, or Type II mechanisms involving energy transfer to molecular
oxygen (see modules on Basic Photosensitization). Both mechanisms may occur simultaneously, and the relative importance depends on the surroundings and the nature of the substrate molecules. Due to the transfer of electrons between the
photosensitizer and substrate in Type I reactions, these reactions are
more likely to occur when the substrate concentration is high. Hypoxic
conditions also favours Type I reactions. The heat released may be used to selectively damage target tissues, and this process is named photothermal sensitization.
The Fluorescence of Photosensitizers
photosensitizers emit some of the energy from the first excited singlet
state as fluorescence. Since the emitted light is usually less
energetic than the absorbed light, the emitted light is usually of
higher wavelength. The energy of light is inversely proportional to the
different spectra are usually measured when the fluorescence properties
of photosensitizers are evaluated, the fluorescence excitation and
emission spectra (Figure 1). The fluorescence excitation spectra are
obtained when the emission is detected at one wavelength, and the
excitation wavelength is varied. For photosensitizers that are in their
monomeric form (not aggregated), the fluorescence excitation spectra and
absorption spectra are identical in shape. Aggregated photosensitizers
usually show low or no fluorescence. A fluorescence emission spectrum
is obtained when the excitation wavelength is kept constant, and the
wavelength for the detection of fluorescence is varied. The difference
between the excitation and emission peak is called the Stoke's shift.
Figure 1. Schematic illustration of fluorescence excitation and emission spectra of dyes.
The fluorescence properties of photosensitizers may be utilized for the
detection of cancers. Many photosensitizers preferentially accumulate
in neoplastic tissues, and their fluorescence properties may be
beneficial in the detection and diagnosis of such lesions (Figure 2). Intravesical instillation of 5-aminolevulinic acid(ALA)-hexyl ester (Hexvix®) (resulting in protoporphyrin IX(PpIX)-based fluorescence) is approved for the detection of bladder cancer, in particular carcinoma in situ
, which is difficult to detect. The fluorescence guided resection of bladder cancer has been found promising for treatment purposes. Similarly, systemic 5-ALA (Gliolan) has been approved for intra-operative fluorescence guided detection of residual glioma, and is used for the further resection of remaining tumor tissue.
Fluorescence emitted from basal carcinomas treated with
5-aminolevulinic acid methyl ester (5-ALA ME). A basal cell carcinoma
is shown in the right figure. The same lesion is treated with
5-ALA ME and 3 hrs later exposed to blue
light. Red fluorescence from protoporphyrin IX induced by 5-ALA ME in
the lesion is shown on the left side.
Efficacy of Photosensitizers in Producing Chemical Changes in Target Molecules
A photosensitizer is defined as a chemical entity, which upon absorption
of light induces a chemical and physical alteration of another chemical
A good photosensitizer should absorb photons efficiently (i.e., high
absorption coefficient), have a high quantum yield of triplet formation,
and the triplet state should be long lived in order to have time to
react with neighbouring target molecules. Most compounds that form
triplet states that are able to produce radicals and reactive oxygen
species have a tricyclic, heterocyclic or porphyrin-like ring
structures with conjugated double bonds (
system). Small changes in the molecular structure may influence the photosensitising property of a compound. A classic example
is the "heavy atom effect" in which replacement of an atom with one of
higher atomic number leads to an increase in the probability of forming
a triplet state, and thereby inducing a photosensitization reaction.
Typically substitution of hydrogen with a halide improves the compound's
properties as a photosensitizer, e.g., bromination of rhodamine 123
to tetrabromorhodamine 123 increases the compound's yield of singlet
oxygen about 50-fold (see below).
Similarly, oxygen may be replaced with sulphur or selenium, and the quantum yield of singlet oxygen formation is dramatically increased, such as in merocyanine 540 (MC540) and Nile blue. The environment of the sensitizer may also influence the
photosensitising properties of the compound. Solvents that lead to
aggregation of the photosensitizer reduce the probabililty of the
compound to undergo intersystem crossing, and most of the energy in the
excited state will be dissipated through nonradiative decay (internal
convertion), producing only heat. Even dimers of the photosensitizer
can be photochemically inactive. The absorption spectrum of aggregated
photosensitizers is usually different from that of the monomeric form.
Binding to proteins or other macromolecules often leads to a redshift
in the absorption spectrum, increased lifetime of the triplet state, and
deaggregation of aggregated species.
Quantum Yield of Photoinactivation
Einstein introduced the concept of quantum yield
which is useful to describe the efficacy of a chromophore in converting
an absorbed photon into a product. The quantum yield is the number of
excited molecules which gives rise to a product divided by the total
number of molecules which have been electronically excited, i.e. the
number of quanta of light absorbed.
can be used to describe the efficacy of absorbed photons in forming any response such as fluorescence (fl
), intersystem crossing
), triplet state (T
) and singlet oxygen (
). This way of expressing efficacy can also be adapted to photoinactivation of cells, in
Usually values for in
are used to compare efficiencies of photoinactivation at different wavelengths, or to compare in
for different sensitizers. In such cases only relative values are
often necessary. When cells are exposed to monochromatic light of the
, the relative quantum yield of photoinactivation, in,rel
) , can be expressed as:
where OD (1
) is the absorption of the chromophore at 1
is the fluence rate given in number of photons per time interval and t
is the time of exposure. This relationship is of practical use only for
fluences that inactivate significantly less that 100% of the cells.
Furthermore, equation 3 holds only for small absorbances and low cell
An action spectrum is a presentation of a measured effect as a function of
the wavelength of excitation. Such spectra can be used to evaluate the
effect of a photosensitizer on producing an event such as cell killing.
Action spectra can be used to document the identity of the
photosensitizer, since the action spectrum will match the absorption
spectrum of the active form of a photosensitizer. The action spectrum
for the photochemical inactivation of cells can be found by measuring the
dose of light necessary for inactivating the same fraction of the cells
at different wavelength, and plotting the results as the dose required
vs. wavelength of excitation light.
In the following, the photosensitizers are grouped on the basis of their
chemical structures, and some of their photosensitizing properties will
be described. In addition some diseases caused by photosensitizers, as
well as drugs inducing skin photosensitivity will be presented.
Specialized photoreceptors such as retinoids and chlorophyll, as well as
non-specialized photoacceptors that may have biostimulatory effects
upon exposure to visible (400-750 nm) light will be described
elsewhere (see modules under Non-Visual Photoreceptors, Vision and Photomorphogenesis). Photosensitizers that are excited by UV light, and are
constituents of most normal cells (e.g., riboflavin and flavin mononucleotide), will not be covered here. Hundreds of different compounds have been shown
to be photosensitizers for biological systems, and only some selected
groups will be presented here.
Porphyrins comprise of four pyrrole subunits linked together by four methine
bridges (Figure 3). This tetrapyrrole ring structure is named
porphin, and derivatives of porphins are named porphyrins. Tetrapyrroles
are naturally occurring pigments, which are used in many biological
processes and include the metallopigments heme (the prosthetic group of
proteins like hemoglobin, cytochromes, catalase, peroxidase and
tryptophane pyrrolase), vitamin B12 , chlorophyll, siroheme (in
nitrite and sulphite reductases) and factor F430 (cofactor of methyl
CoM reductase). All these compounds are synthesized with
uroporphyrinogen III as a common intermediate, and modified to permit
coordination of different metals at the ring centre, i.e., Fe in heme
and siroheme, Mg in chlorophyll, Co in Vitamin B12, and Ni in factor F430 . These tetrapyrroles do not induce any photochemical or
photobiophysical reactions in other compounds or are rapidly quenched
in their normal surroundings, e.g., chlorophyll.
Figure 3. Structure and nomenclature of tetrapyrroles.
By removing the metal, tetrapyrroles become efficient photosensitizers, e.g.,
The presence of a coordinated metal ion and its electronic properties are
of importance for the photocytotoxic potential of porphyrins as
photosensitisers. Most efficient porphyrin-based photosensitizers
generally lack coordinated metal ions. Coordinated metal ions increase
the probability for the nonradiative decay of the triplet state;
paramagnetic metals like Fe3+
being much more efficient than diamagnetic metals like Al3+
. Several metallophotosensitizers have been developed for clinical
purposes. Although in most cases, they have lower quantum yields for
cell inactivation than they would have in the absence of metal ions,
they have other properties like improved solubility and stability,
which makes them interesting as therapeutic substances. The metals used
include Zn, Pd, Sn, Ru, Pt and Al.
Porphyrin-Based Photosensitizers Used in Photodynamic Therapy (PDT)
PDT is a form of photochemotherapy that requires oxygen for its therapeutic
effect, i.e., in PDT a photosensitizer, light and oxygen are all
required. The Type II reaction pathway is expected to be the main
pathway, but Type I reactions involving oxygen may also be involved
(see Basic Photochemistry). PDT has been developed for
cancer treatment, precancereous lesions (actinic keratosis) and
age-related macular degeneration. Most photosensitizers, and all
clinically-approved photosensitizers used in PDT, with the exception of methylene
blue, are based on the tetrapyrrole macrocycle. PDT is
described more completely in the Photomedicine section, and only some properties related to the photosensitizers will be described here.
Porphyrins and porphyrin-related dyes used in PDT have substituents in the
peripheral positions of the pyrrole rings (1-8), on the four methine
carbons (meso-positions), and/or coordinated metals. These derivates are
synthesized to influence the water/lipid solubility, amphiphilicity,
pKa and stability of the compounds. These parameters determine the
biodistribution of the compounds, i.e., the intracellular localization,
tissue distribution and pharmacokinetics.
Hematoporphyrin (Figure 4) was the first porphyrin to
be used on humans in that Dr. Meyer-Betz injected 200 mg of this
compound into himself, and exposed his forearm to light from a Finsen
lamp, and his hands and face to sunlight. The exposed areas showed clear
signs of the photodynamic effect, such as erythema and oedema.
Figure 4. Hematoporhyrin IX.
In the early 1960s, Lipson and colleagues, based upon work by Samuel Schwartz,
tried to purify hematoporhyrin by treating it with sulphuric acid in
acetic acid followed by treatment with alkali and adjusted to pH 7.4 by
means of HCl. Instead of isolating a purified substance, the authors
made a mixture of monomers and oligomers (HpD). The structure of the
most active compounds in this mixture has been much debated, and it has
been suggested that dihematoporphyrin ether or ester is the most
efficient photosensitizer in this mixture. A somewhat purified version was later developed and named Photofrin. This is far from an ideal
photosensitizer for use in PDT, due to its composition and difficulty in
synthesizing reproducible batches. In addition, HpD has far from optimal spectral properties; a long half-life in the body, and skin and eye photosensitivity for 4-6 weeks (or more) after injection. It is approved, however, for use in many indications, and a large number of patients have been treated with this compound.
The absorption spectrum of a porphyrin (Figure 5) comprises a
Soret band and 4 Q-bands. Naturally occurring porphyrins, like in heme
and cytochromes, and melanin are the main chromophores in tissues. If
photoactivation of photosensitizers located deep in a tissue is
required, activation of the outermost Q-band is necessary, because longer
wavelengths of light penetrate tissues better than shorter wavelengths.
However, the absorption coefficient of porphyrins is low at this
wavelength area. New photosensitizers are being developed with a
higher absorption coefficient in this wavelength area and with peak
absorption at higher wavelengths [Figures 5-6, Table 1
(at end of module)]. There is an upper limit, however, for how far into the infrared region a photosensitizer can absorb light and still induce singlet oxygen. This upper limit is
set by the energy required to excite O2
, which is 0.96 eV (22 kcal/mol). The upper wavelength limit is therefore 850-900 nm, depending on the energetic level of the photosensitizers triplet state. The therapeutic window is therefore agreed to be 600-800 nm for in vivo
treatment, limited by haemoglobin and melanin in the low wavelength region.
Figure 5. Photosensitizer Absorbance.
A full spectrum is shown for a porphyrin-type photosensitizer with its typical Soret-band, and the 4 Q-bands. The main peaks and relative absortion coefficients for photosensitizers developed for PDT are indicated on the figure (not to scale).
The porphyrin-type spectrum is caused by the conjugated ring structure with 22
-electrons (Figure 6). An increased absorption coefficient of the
photosensitizer in the red-infrared wavelength region can be obtained
by reducing one or two of the double bonds in the conjugated ring
structure, or by extending the number of conjugated double bonds in the
ring system (Figures 5-6, Table 1
). Conjugated ring structures not directly involved with the inner ring structure, such as phenyl-groups linked to the meso-position of the porphyrins will only influence the
photosensitizer's spectral properties to a minor extent. The effect of
reducing one or two of the double bonds in the porphyrin ring structure
is shown in Figure 5. Porphyrins with one reduced double bond are named
chlorins, and those with two reduced double bonds are named
bacteriochlorins. m-THPC (Foscan) is an example of a chlorin that is
used in clinical PDT, and approved for treatment of squamous cell
carcinomas of the head and neck while the bacteriochlorin
Pd-bacteriochorin is under clinical development. Examples of porphyrins
with an extended ring system are phthalocyanines and naphtalocyanines are shown in Figure 6. Examples of photosensitizers approved, or used in clinical trials, are shown in Figure 7.
Figure 6. Basic structure of some photosensitizers.
Figure 7. Chemical structures of some clinically used photosensitizes. AIPcS2a is the most efficient component of AIPcSn (Photosense).
There are several other photosensitizers that are variants over these themes,
and with side chains that may be beneficial for the compound's
pharmacokinetic properties, or other properties as mentioned above.
Briefly it should only be mentioned that hydrophobic and amphiphilic
phtotosensitzers are generally more efficient in sensitising cells to
photoinactivations due to the longer lifetime of singlet oxygen in
hydrophobic environments, and easier penetration of such
photosensitizers through and into membranes. This is also reflected in all of the photosensitizers that have been approved for clinical use. It should also be
mentioned that many photosensitizers may exist as many ionic species in
biological environments, and some of these may be hydrophobic.
Endogenously Synthesized and Degraded Photosensitizers
5-Aminolevulinic Acid (5-ALA)
is a prodrug for application in PDT and photodynamic
diagnosis that has attracted great attention the last 10 years. 5-ALA-based PDT is approved for treatment of actinic keratosis, 5-ALA-methyl ester based PDT is approved for the treatment of actinic keratosis, basal cell carcinoma and Bowen's disease, while 5-ALA-hexyl ester is approved for the destruction of bladder cancer, as described above in the section on The Fluorescence of Photosensitizers.
Treatment is based on heme synthesis. A main regulatory step in the
heme pathway is linked to 5-ALA synthase activity (Figure 8).
Heme can inhibit the enzyme directly as well as the transcription, translation
and transport of the protein into mitochondria. Thus, treatment of
cells with 5-ALA overrules the regulatory step of the heme pathway, and
induces a high activity through the pathway. Treatment with 5-ALA has
been shown to induce the accumulation of porphyrins, mainly protoporphyrin
IX (PpIX), which sensitizes cells to photoinactivation. All the
intermediates in the heme pathway are porphyrinogens, which are not
photochemically active, but protoporphyrinogens are converted to the
photosentiser PpIX by means of protophorphyrinogen oxidase, or
spontaneously when accumulated in 5-ALA treated cells. Ferrochelatase
into PpIX, and converts it into the
photochemically inactive porphyrin heme. 5-ALA may also act as an
insecticide and a herbicide in a similar way as used for cancer
Figure 8. The heme biosynthetic pathway.
The synthesis occurs partly in the mitochondria, as indicated on the
left side of the figure, and partly in the cytosol. Porphobilinogen,
uroporphyrinogen and coproporphyrinogen may undergo enzymatic or
autooxidative conversion to photochemically active porphyrins, as
indicated on the right side of the figure.
Metabolic errors may cause accumulation of photosensitizers. The most well known
example is the group of diseases known as the porphyrias, which cause the
accumulation of porphyrin intermediates. The synthesis of porphyrin is
described in Figure 8, and porphyrias are caused by lowered activities of
one or more of the enzymes in the heme pathway. Porphyrinogens are
accumulated and are autooxidized to porphyrins. Several
porphyrin-based diseases are described in the literature due to
accumulation of different intermediates leading to somewhat different
symptoms. Some of the most well known porphyrias are described in Table
2. Although all the cells in porphyria patients are affected,
depending on the enzyme defect, mainly erythropoietic cells and liver
accumulate large amounts of porphyrins. These inherited diseases are
therefore classified as erythropoietic or hepatic, depending on the
principal site of expression of the defect.
Table 2 . Classification of the major porphyrias.
Several toxins found in plants, fungi and cyanobacteria cause liver damage or
dysfunction leading to retention of a degradation product of
chlorophyll, phylloerythrin (Figure 9). Chlorophyll is degraded to
phylloerythrin by microorganisms in the rumen of sheep, goat and cattle,
and phylloerythrin is normally modified by the liver to stimulate
excretion through the bile duct. However, certain toxins cause the
accumulation of phylloerythrin, which circulates in the blood,
accumulates in the skin, and causes damage to the skin and eyes of these
animals upon exposure to sunlight. This is a particular problem for
sheep in many countries, e.g., geeldikkop caused by the herb Tribulus terrestris
has affected several hundred thousand sheep and goats in South Africa (Figure 10).
Figure 9. Phylloerythrin.
Figure 10. Examples of damage to animals caused by phylloerythrin accumulation in
the skin and light. The pictures were kindly provided by Professor Arne
Flåøyen, The Norwegian School of Veterinary Science, Norway.
Non-Porphyrin-Based Naturally Occurring Photosensitizers and Derivatives Thereof
have been used in Egypt and India since 1200-2000 BC for the treatment of
the common disfiguring disease, vitiligo. Extracts of leaves, seeds, or
the root of the plant Ammi majus L.
in Egypt and Psoralea corylifolia L.
in India were applied directly on the skin, or ingested, and the patients
exposed to intense sunlight on these areas. It was later found that
the active compounds were psoralens. Purified psoralen was first used
in 1974 in combination with UVA light (PUVA), and PUVA is now used for a
heterogeneous group of diseases such as vitiligo, psoriasis, and mycosis
fungoides (cutaneous T-cell lymphoma). Animals such as cattle and sheep
feeding on psoralen-containing plants may suffer from
photosensitization. Some insects however do have enzymes to detoxify
The basic structure of psoralen is shown in Figure 11. Many psoralens form adducts
with DNA, in particular with thymidine, upon exposure to UV radiation. A
photodynamic reaction pathway leading to the formation of singlet
oxygen has also been documented, and may be involved in damage to cell
membranes as well as DNA. New derivatives of psoralens are under
development to improve selectivity for target tissues, and to increase
phototoxicity in the target area. They are also under development for
viral inactivation of blood products. Gilvocarcins are antitumor
antibiotics with a psoralen-resembling aromatic structure that promotes
protein-DNA cross-linking when photoactivated by near-UV light.
Figure 11. Structure of psoralen (furocoumarin).
(aromatic organic compounds where an even number of -CH= groups are replaced with -(C=O)- are used in
photography, and as dyes, and are widely distributed in plants. Some
quinones, like anthraquinones, perylenequinones and hypericin are
photosensitizers, and will be described here.
(AQs, Figure 12) have been used as dyes, antibiotics, solar energy-storing materials and photosensitizers. Some of these compounds have a high
yield of triplet states upon excitation by light, and form reactive oxygen species (ROS),
including singlet oxygen. The photophysical and photochemical
properties of AQs are significantly influenced by their substituents,
in particular amino and hydroxyl groups that are in most cases
attenuating the T
. Some AQs exhibit quantum yields of singlet oxygen formation comparable to those of porphyrins. Their spectral properties, with a peak
absorption below 600 nm, limit their possible use to superficial lesions.
Figure 12. 9,10-Anthraquinone
, which contain 1.4-dihydroxy-9,10 AQ, represents one of the most
prescribed classes of anticancer agents of which doxorubicin (Figure 13)
and daunorubicin are the best known. The phototoxicity of these compounds is regarded as a side effect, usually seen in patients subjected to sun exposure. The quantum yield of triplet state formation of these
compounds is about 0.2 with a very low
. Light-induced formation of oxygen radicals such as O2-.
have been reported and is markedly enhanced by the presence of electron
donors such as NADH (reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide), L-DOPA (L-3,4-dihydroxy phenylalanine), and ascorbic acid. The peak absorption of
light is usually below 500 nm, which restricts their clinical use,
although imino- or aminosubstitutions cause red-shifted absorption.
Figure 13. Structure of the anthracycline doxorubicin.
Some anthracenediones, i.e., diamino-substituted AQs, have been shown to be good photosensitizers (e.g., 1,5,- and 1,8-diaminoAQs), while others such as
the 1,4-diaminosubstituted AQs mitoxantrone and ametantrone, used as
anticancer agents, have negligible light activation.
of which hypopcrellins (from the parasitic fungi Hypocrella bambuase
and Shiraia bambusicola
) are the most studied for their
photodynamic action (Figure 14). Most of the natural PQs are produced by a large
variety of fungi and act as photodynamic phytotoxins of their hosts.
PQs are efficient 1
generators with quantum yields comparable to those of porphyrins, while O2-.
and other ROS are produced to a lesser extent. The main absorption peak
of hypocrellins is around 450 nm, but they absorb light of wavelengths
up to about 600 nm. Antibacterial (Gram positive) activity has been
observed upon activation by light. PQs in combination with light have
been shown to be good inhibitors of protein kinase C, a key enzyme in
cell proliferation and differentiation.
Figure 14. Hypocrellin A and B.
(HC), structurally related to PQs, is a well known photodynamic agents (Figure 15). HC is isolated from St.John's wort (Hypericum perforatum
). HC is probably the most powerful photosensitizer found in nature, and
quantum yields of singlet oxygen formation of about 0.8 have been
described. A skin disorder (hypericism) is caused in cattle that ingest
large amounts of the Hypericum
plant. It acts through both
Type I and Type II reactions. Its absorption properties, i.e., in the
red wavelength region (peak around 595 nm), make it clinically
favorable for treatment of thin cancer lesions, and it has been evaluated clinically for several cancer indications, and for the detection of bladder cancer. HC has antibiotic properties (on gram-positive bacteria), antiviral effects (specific to enveloped viruses, such as herpes simples, cytomegalovirus and HIV, although no clinical benefits have been documented so far), acts as an inhibitor of protein kinase C, and has also been reported as an antidepressant.
Figure 15. Hypericin and Hypericum perforatum (right side).
Non-Porphyrin-Based Synthetic Photosensitizers
(Figure 16) is a heterocyclic ring system, and may be divided into:
• diphenylmethane derivatives (called pyronines)
• triphenylmethane derivatives, consists mainly of phthaleins, and 9-phenylxanthenes (rosamines)
Figure 16. Xanthene.
may be divided into:
• fluoresceins, which contain hydroxygroups
• rhodamines, which contain amino groups
• mixed types containing both amino and hydroxyl groups
Fluoresceins and rhodamines have been shown to be good photosensitizers, and will be described briefly here.
Figure 17 shows the general structure of the fluorescein group.
Figure 17. Structure of fluoresceins. The R1 and R2 groups consist of only hydrogen in fluorescein, while in rose Bengal R1 is I, and R2 Cl, and in eosin R1 is Br, and R2 H.
was the first photodynamic type photosensitizer tested by Oscar Raab in 1900. Fluorescein is a poor photosensitizer, but by replacing some of
the hydrogens with halides, these compounds become efficient
photosensitizers (Figure 17). Rose Bengal is often used as a generator of
~ 0.7). Due to their negative charge only gram-positive bacterias are
photoinactivated by the fluoresceins. Erythrosin B (R1=I, R2=H in
Figure16) also used as a food additive, is approved by the Environmental
Protection agency in USA as a photoinsecticide controlling houseflies
in poultry facilities. The absorption peak of fluoresceins is typically
in the 450-500 nm range and fluoresce in the 500-550 nm range.
The most used and studied rhodamine is rhodamine 123 (Rh123, Figure 18). It is much used as a mitochondrial stain. This localization is due to its delocalised positive charge, which traps Rh123 in the negatively
charged matrix of the mitochondria. It has a high quantum yield of
~ 0.9), and therefore a low yield of triplet state, which is also shown to be short-lived. However, the triplet state has been shown to mediate
both Type I and II photosensitization.
Figure 18. Structure of rhodamine 123.
The quantum yield for 1
formation is dramatically improved by bromination of Rh123 (e.g., tetrabromo Rh123), enhancing the
from negligible to about 0.7, and increasing the triplet life-time
10-fold. Rh123 has been evaluated for its phototherapeutic properties
on a large variety of cancer cells with somewhat conflicting results.
TetrabromoRh123 as well as Rh3G and 6G has been shown superior to
Rh123 with respect to sensitising cells to photoinactivation due to the
higher quantum yield for 1
cellular uptake. Systemic toxicity has been reported with these
compounds. Rh123 has been shown to accumulate preferentially in some
carcinoma cells. However, the spectral properties of rhodamines
(similar to fluoresceins) restrict their use to thin lesions.
Alkylation of amino groups or halogenation introduce some red
shift of the light absorption spectra. A dibrominated rhodamine
derivative has been granted orphan drug designation by the U.S. Food
and Drug Administration (FDA) to treat patients with chronic myeloid
leukemia (CML) ex vivo
. The positive charge of rhodamines makes it vulnerable for multi-drug resistance transporters.
dyes contain two heterocyclic systems connected by a bond between nuclear carbon atoms (apocyanines). The two hetereocycles can be linked
through methine groups, i.e., monomethines (cyanines) or polymethines
(polycarbocyanines). These compounds were originally used in
photographic emulsions, but have later been found to be good
photosensitizers, and have been explored for diagnostic and therapeutic
purposes. The most used cyanine dyes for phototherapeutic purposes are
merocyanine 540 (MC540), kryptocyanine and chalcogenapyrylium. The
absorption properties of these compounds (max
around 550 nm) limit their use to thin lesions, or by other means where
light penetration through tissue is not a limitation. In general,
increasing the length of the polymethine chain increases the max
, but also destabilize the compounds.
MCD540 (Figure 19) has a high selectivity and affinity for leukemia, lymphomas
and neuroblastoma in autologous bone marrow grafts, and has undergone
clinical trials for these purposes. The phototoxicity of MC540 is due
to a photodynamic process involving 1
. MC540 PDT targets membrane lipids, especially in the plasma membrane. Pre-exposure of MC540 to light leads to photoproducts that inhibit topoisomerase II, a main target in cancer therapy.
Figure 19. MC540
(carbocyanines, Figure 20) have a delocalised positive charge, and will, as does Rh123, penetrate through membranes due to their hydrophobic character, and
concentrate in the negatively charged mitochondrial matrix. The yield
of triplet state and 1
formation of these dyes
is low. Internal conversion from the first excited state to the ground
state is efficient, and the heat produced may generate a phototoxic
effect. N,N'-bis(2-ethyl-1,3-dioxolane)kryptocyanine (EDKC) has shown
interesting phototherapeutic properties, but little research has been performed
Figure 20. Kryptocyanine.
(Figure 21) are also cationic, and target the mitochondria
preferentially. Se/Te chalcogenapyrylium has been most studied, and has an
absorption maximum at 770 nm, with a relatively low
(<0.1). Photochemical instability and dark toxicity preclude their use in PDT.
Figure 21. Chalcogenapyrylium dyes, where O, Se or Te have been used in positions R1 and R2.
Triarylmethane photosensitizers are cationic dyes related to the cyanines and exhibit properties similar to these. Victoria blue-BO
(VBBO, Figure 22) is the best studied and has been shown to target
Figure 22. Victoria Blue BO
Phenothiazines, Phenoxazines and Acridines.
The structures of phenothiazine and phenoxazine are shown in Figure 23. The
phenothiazines dye methylene blue (MB) is widely used as a vital stain
(as is also the case for toluidine blue (TBO)), in diagnosis and as a
tumor marker during surgery. MB and TBO are also under development for
pathogen reduction in blood products (MB is currently used by the Swiss
and German Red Cross for this purpose), and bacterial eradication in
dental plaques. The eradication of gram-negative bacteria is very efficient
with TBO, probably due in part to its positive charge, which seems to be
a prerequisite for the efficient photodynamic eradication of such
bacterias. A large variety of phenothiazines have been synthesized, of
which MB, TBO, azure A-C and thionin are the most well known. Both
phenothiazines and phenoxazines are good producers of 1
but other reactive species seems also to be involved in the
photodynamic activity of these compounds.
Of the phenothiazines, only methylene blue has been evaluated clinically on inoperable oesophageal tumors by intratumoral injection of the photosensitizer. Derivatives of methylene blue are undergoing clinical trials for the treatment of chronic skin ulcers.
Phenothiazines, phenoxazines and acridine cationic dyes accumulate in
acidic vesicles like the lysosomes, while the cyanine cationic dyes
accumulate mainly in the mitochondria. This pattern may, however, be
influenced by the side chains on the compounds and the extracellular
concentration. These compounds have also high affinity for DNA by
intercalating into the double strand.
Some of these compounds (acridine orange (AO), TBO,
pyronine Y) also bind RNA and damage RNA in a photodynamic manner, involving the formation of 1
It should be noted that phenothiazines and phenoxazines (at least MB
and TBO) are reduced intracellularly by reducing agents such as NADH
, forming leuco MB/TBO, which is colourless and
photodynamiclly inactive. The phenothiazines and phenoxazines have
favourable spectral properties for therapeutic utilization with strong
absorption in the 600-660 nm range. Nile blue has very low
except when oxygen is replaced with a heavier atom effect such as S or Se.
Figure 23. Chemical structure of phenothiazines, phenoxazines and acridines and some
examples of regularly used dyes of these classes of compounds.
Chemicals that Cause Unwanted Biological Effects upon Exposure to Light
Several widely used medicaments have photosensitizers properties, which may
cause skin reactions upon exposure to light. Most of these compounds
are di- or tricyclic aromatic molecules, which are activated by UVA or
UVB light. The photosensitization reactions may be due to the drugs
themselves, their metabolites, and toxic reactions may be caused by the
photoproducts. These drugs may cause dermatitis, erythema, bleb
formation, itching and burning sensation during sun exposure. Examples
of such photosensitiers are quinolones, tetracyclins, sulfonamides,
phentiazine derivatives (antihistamines), non-steroid ant-inflammatory
agents (NSAIDs), and chloroquine. Uroporhyrin has been shown to
accumulate after treatment with steroids, antibiotics, hypnotics and
sedatives. Some anthraquinone dyes used in textile industry may cause
skin reactions known as bikini dermatitis. Cosmetic products (cologne,
perfumes) that contain naturally occurring furanocoumarins, may induce
a skin condition known as berloque dermatitis. Exposure to sunlight may
cause phototoxic reactions leading to pigmentation, which may last for
a long time. It should also be cautioned that medical drugs can undergo photochemical reactions before use, and cause attenuated clinical responses or unexpected side effects.
A large number of photosensitizers have been evaluated for potential clinical use. Many of these photosensitizers absorb light below 600 nm, thus limiting their therapeutic use to superficial lesions. The treatment of thicker tissue layers requires photosensitizers that absorb light above 600 nm. A large number of photosensitizers with such a property have been developed in the last 20 years, and are currently being evaluated in clinical trials, mainly for various cancers. The specificities of these photosensitizers to target lesions are still too low, and current and future research is focused on technologies to solve this problem.
Ali H, van Lier JE. (1999) Metal complexes as photo- and radiosensitizers. Chem. Rev. 99:2379-450.
Bonnett,R. (1999) Photodynamic therapy in historic perspective. Rev.Contemp.Pharmacother. 10: 1-17.
Brown SB, Brown EA, Walker I.(2004) The present and future role of photodynamic therapy in cancer treatment. Lancet. Oncol. 2004 5:497-508.
Corash, L. (2001) Inactivation of infectious pathogens in labile blood components: meeting the challenge. Transfus. Clin. Biol.8:138-45.
Kagan,J. (1993) Organic photochemistry. Principles and applications. Academic Press.
MacDonald,I.J. and Dougherty,T.J. (1999) Basic principles of photodynamic therapy. J. Porphyrins and Phthalocyanines. 5:105-129.
Morgan J, Oseroff AR. (2001) Mitochondria-based photodynamic anti-cancer therapy. Adv. Drug Deliv. Rev. 49:71-86.
O'Connor AE, Gallagher WM, Byrne AT. (2009) Porphyrin and nonporphyrin photosensitizers in oncology: preclinical and clinical advances in photodynamic therapy. Photochem. Photobiol. 85:1053-74.
Redmond, R.W. and Gamlin, J.N. (1999) A compilation of singlet oxygen yields from biologically relevant molecules. Photochem. Photobiol. 70:391-475.
Roberts JE. (2002) Screening for ocular phototoxicity. Int. J. Toxicol. 21:491-500.
Theodossiou TA, Hothersall JS, De Witte PA, Pantos A, Agostinis P (2009) The Multifaceted Photocytotoxic Profile of Hypericin. Mol. Pharm. e-pub
Tønnesen,H.H. (2001) Formulation and stability testing of photolabile drugs. Int. J. Pharmaceutics. 225: 1-14.
Sobolev AS, Jans DA, Rosenkranz AA. (2000) Targeted intracellular delivery of photosensitizers. Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol. 73:51-90.
Wainwright M, Mohr H, Walker WH. (2007) Phenothiazinium derivatives for pathogen inactivation in blood products. J. Photochem. Photobiol. B. 86:45-58.
Wainwright,M. (2000) Methylene blue derivatives - suitable photoantimicrobials for blood product disinfection? Int. J. Antimicrob. Agents. 16: 381-394.
Zarebska Z, Waszkowska E, Caffieri S, Dall'Acqua F. (2000) PUVA (psoralen + UVA) photochemotherapy: processes triggered in the cells. Farmaco. 55:515-20.
[ Return to Text ]
[ TOP ]